The philosophical discussion of socrates theory of recollection

Such as, in meno, the discussion between socrates and meno about virtue is the most representative example of socrates's pursuit of true knowledge 771 words - 3 pages the main argument plato expressed in phaedo (through socrates) regarding the theory of recollection and his philosophy on the immortality of the. Society for ancient greek philosophy newsletter by an authorized administrator of the open repository @ binghamton (the orb) for more information eristic puzzle, the doctrine of recollection, socrates' interrogation of meno's slave-boy, and elenctic, socratic inquiries and platonic discussions with. No contemporary scholar of ancient philosophy has studied plato's epistemology in greater depth than gail on the theory of recollection, this guarantees that genuine knowledge also satisfies the condition that 'intellection' (noēsis) and ' knowledge' (epistēmē) between the discussion of the divided line in book vi. Theory of recollection, we must look at socrates's questioning of meno's slave we must note first what the slave brings with him into the discussion he already speaks greek he already has the concepts necessary to follow socrates's questions and respond to them intelligently for example, he recognizes and can deploy. Cebes mentions that the soul's immortality also is supported by socrates' theory that learning is “recollection” (a theory which is the conclusion of the second argument for the soul's immortality extends what has been said about equality to other forms as well: “if. Ed fraser argues that the theory of recollection presented by socrates in the meno is circular can read four articles free per month to have complete access to the thousands of philosophy articles on this site, please this problem of finding a definition of something is known as 'the paradox of enquiry' socrates argues. The phaedo's discussion of recollection begins with a remark by cebes in support of the claim that our souls preexist their incarceration in the body: “such is also the case if that theory is true that you are accustomed to mention frequently, that for us learning is no other than.

Meno is a socratic dialogue written by plato (steph 70–100) it appears to attempt to determine the definition of virtue, or arete, meaning virtue in general, rather than particular virtues, such as justice or temperance the first part of the work is written in the socratic dialectical style and meno is reduced to confusion or aporia. The precepts of the theory of recollection, this renders possible the evaluation of truth claims with reference meno responds in the affirmative5 plato's identification of the character meno with the philosophical views in contrast, socrates insists that his definition of shape is superior to his definition of colour and that meno. While all of socrates' arguments for the existence of an eternal soul are faulty, socrates so-called recollection theory, which looks to the supposedly prenatal as a result, socrates is able to discuss a soul without having to really explain what he means by it, and even contemporary philosophers are continually forced to. By ben potter the phaedo takes places in 399 bc at the scene of the final days of socrates' life the dialogue is primarily an argument for the immortality.

Implication of his interpretation of this theory is retained in the epistemological sections of plato's republic this implication is the idea that only philosophical learning makes use of cognitive abilities beyond sensation scott points to two sections of the republic in defense of this claim: the discussion of the 'lovers of sight. Video created by university of pennsylvania for the course ancient philosophy: plato & his predecessors what is virtue, and how can it be taught what is teaching anyway, and how could we ever acquire knowledge socrates gives a geometry.

Considering only plato's arguments from opposites and recollection, an explanation and critique are given i suggest that the argument from in order to grasp the concept of absolute such and such, a person merely needs their imagination, opinion, or definition introduction the phaedo surrounds the. By calling them 'philosophical' arguments i am distinguishing them from arguments which are based on empirical research, like research into near-death experiences, and from arguments which rely on premises taken from a particular religious tradition we will discuss empirical and religious arguments. That is why socrates is surprised that they are not accustomed to thinking of philosophy as a preparation for death one of his arguments is that, given the doctrine of recollection, the soul must exist prior to birth and therefore must be able to exist after death as well (72e-73a) we pick the discussion up at 95a cebes.

The most illustrious student socrates had in philosophy was plato, whose beautifully written dialogues not only offered an admiring account of the teachings of his this is the doctrine of recollection, plato's conviction that our most basic knowledge comes when we bring back to mind our acquaintance with eternal realities. While some scholars, for example welbourne (1986: 231) point to the fact the paradox could be a mere riddle made in jest, socrates (or plato) “appreciates the tricksy nature of the puzzle” and uses it to reveal a deeper philosophical theory, namely that of recollection the paradox raises the immediate. 11 summary of plato's phaedo: 12 the argument of opposites: 13 the theory of recollection: 14 the argument of immateriality: 15 the theory of forms and participation: a number of friends gather socrates in his cell, including his old friend crito and two pythagorean philosophers, simmias and cebes socrates. Even the most cursory overview of pre-socratic philosophy will show that many of the pre- socratics dealt with the discussion of opposites was his elucidation of when it is possible to predicate a pair of opposites of the the opposite ideas, comes from the theory of recollection presented in the phaedo at some time.

The philosophical discussion of socrates theory of recollection

the philosophical discussion of socrates theory of recollection My second concern is that fine minimizes the theory of recollection fine argues that socrates replies to meno in three stages: (1) initial mention of the theory of recollection, (2) an interlude where socrates cross-examines one of meno's slaves about geometry, and (3) a second discussion of recollection.

Socrates now re-introduces the theory of forms, making simmias agree that there is such a thing as equality itself--something that is independent of any the theory of recollection is laid out in more detail in plato's meno, and the discussion in the phaedo alludes to, and seems to assume prior knowledge of, this earlier. 5 days ago ancient greek philosophy: from the presocratics to the hellenistic philosophers meno tries to enlighten socrates, but unlike interlocutors in previous dialogues devoted to a search for a definition, meno has considerable trouble providing the right sort of answer to the what is virtue question, and.

  • I want to tie plato's radical nativism (the idea that some or all human knowledge and concepts are innate) to contemporary debates in the philosophy of mind and cognitive science regarding the difficulties around concept learning (specifically the arguments of jerry fodor) and suggest that those of us concerned with the.
  • Meno's 1st definition of virtue: virtue is relative to the sort of person in question, eg the virtue of a woman is to be good at managing a household and to be submissive to her the idea that virtue is a kind of knowledge, however, does seem to have been a central tenet of plato's moral philosophy.
  • This is a video in my new core concepts series -- designed to provide students and lifelong learners a brief discussion focused on one main concept from a classic philosophical text and thinker this video focuses on plato's dialogue, the meno, and examines the platonic doctrine of recollection as.

24200: ancient philosophy prof how will you look for [the definition of virtue] socrates, when you do not know at all what it is how will you aim to in the discussion which follows, socrates proposes to resolve this paradox of inquiry with his doctrine of recollection ii what is the doctrine of recollection socrates. One of the most important features of plato's philosophy, a feature which he appears to have taken over from socrates, is the view that when we attribute theaetetus's first statement seems to be an inference from perception's being a necessary condition for knowledge to the conclusion that perception is identical or. Theory of forms a discussion note filozofia 66, 2011, no 4, p 353 it is often assumed that: (a) in his early dialogues plato uses the character of socrates corpus, plato expounds his own philosophical ideas 3 in metaphysics a 6 987b1-10, aristotle makes some interesting comments about socrates and plato 4.

the philosophical discussion of socrates theory of recollection My second concern is that fine minimizes the theory of recollection fine argues that socrates replies to meno in three stages: (1) initial mention of the theory of recollection, (2) an interlude where socrates cross-examines one of meno's slaves about geometry, and (3) a second discussion of recollection. the philosophical discussion of socrates theory of recollection My second concern is that fine minimizes the theory of recollection fine argues that socrates replies to meno in three stages: (1) initial mention of the theory of recollection, (2) an interlude where socrates cross-examines one of meno's slaves about geometry, and (3) a second discussion of recollection. the philosophical discussion of socrates theory of recollection My second concern is that fine minimizes the theory of recollection fine argues that socrates replies to meno in three stages: (1) initial mention of the theory of recollection, (2) an interlude where socrates cross-examines one of meno's slaves about geometry, and (3) a second discussion of recollection. the philosophical discussion of socrates theory of recollection My second concern is that fine minimizes the theory of recollection fine argues that socrates replies to meno in three stages: (1) initial mention of the theory of recollection, (2) an interlude where socrates cross-examines one of meno's slaves about geometry, and (3) a second discussion of recollection.
The philosophical discussion of socrates theory of recollection
Rated 5/5 based on 45 review